Articles
, Founder and Chairman
Aluminium, compostable or reusable cups? What the research says about carbon, cost and return rates, and why single-use is the real problem.

In 2025 Wembley served every draught beer and cocktail across Coldplay’s ten-night run in aluminium cups. Around 400,000 plastic cups were never needed. It was a first for a UK stadium at that scale, and it got a lot of deserved attention.
There’s one number I’d love to know, and Wembley didn’t publish it: how many times was each of those aluminium cups actually used?
That isn’t a criticism of Wembley. It’s the question I think every venue should be asking, whatever cup it chooses. Stadiums, attractions, cafés and hospitality operators are all under pressure to get rid of single-use plastic, and many are responding by switching to aluminium, paper or compostable cups. Some of those switches help. Some just swap one kind of single-use cup for another.
The United Nations Environment Programme reviewed the lifecycle research on single-use products in 2021 and reached a conclusion that has stayed with me: the bigger problem is “single-use”, not “plastic”. Change the material and keep throwing the cup away, and you haven’t changed much.
Are aluminium cups better for the environment?
Aluminium looks premium, feels cold in the hand with a chilled drink, and recycles well. I understand why venues like it, particularly for stadium cups. Some are now using machines that take the lid off a can so people can drink straight from it, with no separate cup at all.
But the carbon picture is not what most people assume.
The most thorough comparison I’ve seen for events is Reuse Wins at Events, a lifecycle assessment led by Dr John Wentz at the University of St. Thomas for the campaign group Upstream. It was first published in 2021 and revised in November 2025. It modelled 16oz cups at US arenas and stadiums and found that single-use aluminium cups used 47% more energy over their lifecycle and produced 86% more CO2 than single-use PET and PLA plastic cups. Its authors describe single-use aluminium as the worst option for the climate by far.
Those figures reflect that study’s assumptions about cup weight, recycled content and recycling rates. Not every aluminium cup will score the same. The direction of travel is hard to argue with, though.
The reason is the metal itself. Making new aluminium means mining bauxite, refining it and smelting it with huge amounts of electricity. According to the International Aluminium Institute, global primary aluminium production emitted around 14.8 tonnes of CO2e for every tonne of metal in 2023.
Recycling helps enormously: it uses around 95% less energy than making aluminium from scratch. But a cup has to be collected, sorted and remelted to get that benefit. And even when it is, the next drink still needs a new cup.
So what did Wembley actually show?
It showed that a major stadium can take plastic cups out of the bar at real scale. That matters.
Wembley reported collecting more than a tonne of aluminium cups and cans for recycling, with plans to turn some of it into musical shakers for local schools. Its waste partner Veolia recorded a recycling rate of 72% on the fifth night. That is a venue-wide recycling figure, though, not the share of cups that came back to be used again.
What it didn’t show is how many uses each cup achieved, or whether the switch cut lifecycle emissions overall. Without that, you can’t tell whether you’re running a reuse system or a very well-organised recycling one.
Replacing plastic waste with aluminium waste is still waste.
Are compostable cups actually compostable?
Compostable coffee cups, usually made from PLA or from paperboard with a compostable lining, are marketed as the guilt-free option. Whether they live up to that depends almost entirely on which bin they end up in.
The European standard for industrially compostable packaging, EN 13432, tests materials at around 58°C and requires at least 90% biodegradation within six months. A garden compost heap gets nowhere near that, and nor does a hedge.
In England, the rules are now explicit. Under Simpler Recycling, government guidance for workplaces says packaging labelled compostable or biodegradable cannot go in with food waste. Businesses either arrange a dedicated collection or treat it as general waste. In practice, a lot of compostable cups are incinerated or sent to landfill.
Compostable doesn’t automatically mean lower-carbon either. UNEP’s review of ten lifecycle assessments of drinks cups found that single-use cups made from conventional plastic, bioplastic and paper can all have broadly similar impacts, depending on how they’re made and how they’re disposed of.
Compostability tells you what a cup can do in the right conditions. It doesn’t remove the impact of making, shipping and disposing of a new one for every drink.
How many uses before a reusable cup breaks even?
A reusable cup costs more in material and manufacturing than a disposable one. The difference is that you pay that once and spread it across every drink the cup serves.
The Upstream study is useful here as well. It found that reusable polypropylene and stainless steel cups beat single-use plastic after around five or six uses. Against single-use aluminium the break-even comes even sooner: two or three uses. Polypropylene cups can go through hundreds of washes, and stainless steel thousands.
Other studies come up with higher break-even points, especially where washing uses more energy or water. A peer-reviewed 2021 study by Cottafava and colleagues found the answer depends on the cup material, how it’s washed, how far it travels and what happens to it at the end. So I wouldn’t treat six as a magic number.
In my experience, break-even is the easy part. Getting the cup back, again and again, is what decides whether a reusable cup scheme works at all. A cup built for 1,000 washes does very little good if it walks out of the gate after its third drink. I’ve written about the mistakes that cause that. Across our own schemes, at venues including Blenheim Palace and the Eden Project, we consistently see return rates of 95% and above. That is where the environmental case is actually won.
Do reusable cups save venues money?
Sustainability arguments get a venue’s attention. Cost arguments get a decision.
Our two longest-running schemes show what happens when reuse is done well. At Blenheim Palace, drinks packaging costs fell by 50% in the second year of reuse, and each cup pays for itself in around four uses compared with the single-use cups it replaced. At the Eden Project, the cafés saved around £25,000 on single-use cup supplies in 2024, by Eden’s own calculations. As David Green, Blenheim’s Head of Innovation, put it: “Sustainability is no longer a trade-off against profitability.”
Those savings depend on one thing: cups coming back. Eden learned that the hard way. In its first scheme, deposits were refunded at the till, so visitors had to queue again to get their money back, and fewer than half the cups were returned. Once return machines with instant card refunds were in place, the return rate rose to 96%. Same cups, same visitors; the only change was how easy it was to hand a cup back.
It isn’t only our schemes. August Hall, a 951-capacity music venue in San Francisco, switched from compostable cups to reusables under Clean Water Action’s independent ReThink Disposable programme. After paying roughly $13,000 a year for the reusable cup service, it projected $29,700 a year in net savings, with a 91% return rate in its first four months.
The number I’d encourage any operator to track is the total cost per drink served: cups, washing, handling, losses and waste collection all in. If you hire your cups, it’s also worth checking what’s really on the invoice.
Reusable plastic vs reusable aluminium cups
Once you’ve decided to reuse, the material question matters a lot less. Both can work well. They suit different venues.
Reusable polypropylene | Reusable aluminium | |
|---|---|---|
Durability | Light, tough, built for repeated commercial washing | Can be durable, but thin-walled designs dent |
Carbon to make | Generally lower per kilo | Higher, unless it’s mostly recycled metal |
End of life | Recyclable, RFID tag included, where collection exists | Very well established recycling |
Cold drinks | Fine | Great, with that cold-to-the-touch feel |
Hot drinks | Fine with the right specification | Thin, uninsulated cups get too hot to hold |
Tracking | RFID or QR codes | QR codes are simpler, because metal interferes with RFID |
Aluminium conducts heat roughly a thousand times better than polypropylene. That’s why an aluminium pint feels so cold, and also why a thin aluminium coffee cup will burn your fingers. It doesn’t keep a drink cold for longer, either; it just passes the heat from your hand straight into your beer.
My rule of thumb: for a stadium serving mostly cold drinks, aluminium is a reasonable choice. For a café or a mixed hospitality site, polypropylene is the more versatile one. Either way, buy a cup that’s genuinely designed for commercial washing, not one made for a handful of refills.
Can reusable plastic cups with RFID tags be recycled?
Yes. People sometimes assume a chip in a cup makes it unrecyclable. It doesn’t. At the end of their working life, our RFID-tagged polypropylene cups can be recycled whole, with the tag left in place. There’s no need to cut it out first.
The research backs this up. A 2024 study led by the University of Manchester put plastic packaging with RFID tags through mechanical recycling and found the process and the quality of the recycled plastic were unaffected. Earlier pilot-scale recycling trials in Spain reached the same conclusion. The tag makes up a tiny fraction of the cup’s weight.
There are two caveats worth being honest about. Every recycling facility works slightly differently, so it’s worth confirming the process with your recycling partner. And the recycled polypropylene will usually go into other products, such as garden furniture, rather than back into food-grade cups. That’s still a long way better than landfill, and it comes after hundreds of uses rather than one.
Making a reusable cup scheme work
Whatever you serve in, the success of a reuse scheme is decided after the drink is finished. The cup has to come back easily, get washed, and go straight back into circulation. And you need to know how many cups you’re losing, how often each one is used and what the whole system really costs.
That’s the part we’ve spent years building at re-universe. Every cup gets its own digital identity, so serving, returns, washing and reporting are all connected. Plastic cups can be tracked with RFID or QR codes; for aluminium, QR codes are the practical option. I’ve written more about how the two compare.
Our deposit return scheme works through the customer’s own bank card, so there’s no app to download and no account to create, and refunds come back in seconds. I’m firmly against making anyone download anything to have a drink.
That means a venue can choose the cup that suits its customers and still see exactly how its reuse system is performing.
The bottom line
Aluminium is highly recyclable. Compostable cups can be the right answer where the collection and processing exist. Conventional plastic is light and cheap. But none of those things matter much if the cup is thrown away after one drink.
The research consistently points the same way: reuse is the better option once cups are used enough times and washed efficiently. And when returns are high, it can also cost less.
Reusable plastic and reusable aluminium can both be good choices. The decision that matters is to stop throwing cups away and keep them circulating for as long as you can.
If you’re weighing up a reusable cup scheme for your venue, see how our returnable cup system works, or read how it’s running at Blenheim Palace, the Eden Project and others.
Frequently asked questions
Are aluminium cups recyclable?
Yes, aluminium recycles very well and uses around 95% less energy than making new metal. But a single-use aluminium cup still has a higher carbon footprint than a single-use plastic one, and every drink needs a new cup.
Can compostable cups go in food waste?
Not in England. Under Simpler Recycling rules, packaging labelled compostable or biodegradable can’t go in with food waste. Businesses need a dedicated collection or must treat it as general waste.
How many times does a reusable cup need to be used?
In one major events study, reusable polypropylene and stainless steel cups beat single-use plastic after around five or six uses, and single-use aluminium after two or three. Other studies find higher numbers, depending on washing and transport.
Do reusable cups save money?
They can, when return rates are high. Blenheim Palace cut its drinks packaging costs by half in its second year of reuse, and the Eden Project saved around £25,000 on single-use cups in 2024.
Are reusable plastic or aluminium cups better?
Both work. Aluminium suits venues serving mainly cold drinks; polypropylene is more versatile, handles hot drinks and is lighter.
Can reusable cups with RFID tags be recycled?
Yes. Research shows RFID tags don’t affect the recycling process or the quality of the recycled plastic, so our polypropylene cups can be recycled whole with the tag in place. Check the details with your recycling partner. The plastic usually becomes other products rather than new cups.
Sources and further reading
Upstream / Wentz, University of St. Thomas (2021, revised Nov 2025): Reuse Wins at Events
Cottafava et al. (2021): Assessment of the environmental break-even point for deposit return systems
Clean Water Action (2024): San Francisco music venues reusable cup case study
Aliaga et al. (2011): Influence of RFID tags on recyclability of plastic packaging
Financial Times: How reusable coffee cups are turning smarter payments into smart savings